The global coffee industry, a complex web of farmers, traders, roasters, and consumers, is facing a critical juncture. The latest Sustainable Coffee Purchases Report 2025, released by the nonprofit Global Coffee Platform (GCP), reveals a concerning trend: a decrease in the proportion of green coffee purchased by 14 major coffee roasters and retailers that meets recognized sustainability standards. This marks the first reported decline in this key metric after several years of steady gains, raising important questions about the efficacy and direction of current sustainability efforts within the sector.

According to the report, approximately 69% of green coffee purchased by these 14 major industry players in 2025 adhered to a recognized baseline sustainability standard. This figure represents a drop from the 75% recorded in the preceding year, 2024. The GCP’s annual report, which has been published on a near-annual basis since 2018, serves as a vital barometer for tracking the industry’s commitment to more responsible sourcing practices. While the number of participating companies in the reporting initiative has increased, the overall share of sustainably sourced coffee has faltered.

A Shift in Sourcing Strategies: The JDE Peet’s Factor

The Global Coffee Platform attributes the overall decline in sustainable coffee purchases primarily to a significant shift in sourcing practices by one major company. While GCP’s announcement did not explicitly name the company, its own data within the report highlights JDE Peet’s, one of the largest global coffee buyers, as a key influencer in this trend.

JDE Peet’s recorded a substantial decrease in its purchases meeting GCP-recognized standards, falling from 72.94% in 2024 to 47.04% in 2025. In its commentary accompanying the report, JDE Peet’s explained this evolution as part of its ongoing “journey” to refine its responsible sourcing approach. The company has transitioned from a primary focus on certification- and verification-based sourcing to a more human rights and environmental due diligence (HREDD) risk-based approach. Under this alternative framework, JDE Peet’s reported that an impressive 88.8% of its green coffee was responsibly sourced in 2025, indicating a different methodology for assessing sustainability. This divergence in reporting methodologies between companies, even within the same initiative, underscores the complexities of measuring and comparing sustainability progress across the industry.

Historical Trends and Evolving Participation

The GCP’s Sustainable Coffee Purchases Report has consistently tracked progress in the industry’s embrace of sustainability. The 2024 report, for instance, showcased a record high of 75.36% of purchases meeting the GCP baseline. This followed a 73% figure in 2023 and 70% in 2022. The latest 2025 figure of 69.3% signifies a reversal of this upward trajectory.

It is important to note that year-to-year comparisons can be nuanced due to changes in the companies participating in the reporting initiative and the range of eligible sustainability programs. In 2025, the initiative welcomed three new companies: Lidl, NewCoffee, and Ringtons, bringing the total number of participating roasters and retailers to 14. Concurrently, the number of sustainability programs recognized for reporting purposes expanded from 26 to 30, suggesting a broadening scope of what is considered sustainable. Despite these expansions, the core metric of overall sustainable coffee purchase share has seen a dip.

Key Data Points from the 2025 Report

Beyond the headline figure, the 2025 report offers deeper insights into the dynamics of sustainable coffee procurement:

  • Total Volumes Purchased: The total volume of coffee purchased through GCP-recognized sustainability programs in 2025 was approximately 1.58 million metric tons. This represents an 8.9% decrease compared to the 1.74 million metric tons reported in 2024. In contrast, the total reported coffee purchases, including conventional coffee, saw a more modest decline of less than 1%, totaling approximately 2.29 million metric tons. This indicates that while overall coffee consumption remained relatively stable, the proportion of that consumption sourced through recognized sustainability channels experienced a more pronounced reduction.

  • Verification vs. Certification Schemes: A significant factor contributing to the overall decline was a notable decrease in volumes purchased through "2nd Party Assurance Systems." These systems typically encompass the in-house verification programs developed by roasters and traders, or tailored schemes from organizations like Enveritas. Volumes acquired through these types of programs saw a substantial 26% decrease in 2025. Conversely, volumes purchased through established third-party certification schemes, such as 4C, Fairtrade, and Rainforest Alliance, remained relatively stable. This divergence suggests a potential shift away from internal or less rigorously audited sustainability initiatives towards more widely recognized and independently verified standards, or perhaps a recalibration of how these 2nd party systems are counted or implemented.

  • Narrowing Geographic Diversity: Despite the increase in participating companies, the geographic diversity of reported sustainable coffee purchases has actually narrowed. In 2025, sustainable coffee was reported as originating from 30 producing countries, down from 34 in the previous year. Brazil and Vietnam emerged as the dominant sources, accounting for approximately 61% of the reported sustainable coffee volume. This concentration raises questions about the equitable distribution of sustainability initiatives and their impact across a wider range of coffee-producing regions.

Procurement: An Enduring Industry Challenge

The findings of the GCP report arrive at a critical moment, as sustainability organizations and industry stakeholders increasingly focus on the intricate relationship between commercial procurement practices and the persistent challenges of poverty among coffee farmers. For decades, despite numerous corporate sustainability commitments and initiatives, economic insecurity and poverty remain pervasive issues for many coffee farmers and farmworkers. Analysis from the 2026 Coffee Barometer, for instance, revealed that the average coffee-farming household in eight of the world’s ten largest producing countries falls short of meeting living income benchmarks.

This reality underscores the limitations of simply tracking purchase volumes as a sole indicator of progress. As the GCP itself stated in its report announcement, "purchase volumes alone cannot show whether sustainability efforts are improving outcomes for farmers, strengthening supply chain resilience, or supporting the transition to more sustainable and regenerative coffee production." This highlights a growing recognition within the industry that a more nuanced approach to measuring impact is required, one that looks beyond the quantity of sustainably certified beans to the tangible benefits for the people and ecosystems at the source.

Towards More Responsible Procurement Principles

In response to these persistent challenges, collaborative efforts are underway to redefine procurement practices within the coffee sector. In March, the Global Coffee Platform, in conjunction with IDH and Solidaridad, published "shared procurement principles." These principles, developed with the input of 14 major coffee traders and roasters, emphasize the importance of fostering longer-term relationships, accurately accounting for the costs of coffee production, and adopting a greater consideration of shared risk within the supply chain.

This initiative was further expanded in September through a collaboration with the German development agency GIZ. This partnership aims to develop specific guidance and practical tools to help companies implement these principles more effectively. The overarching goal is to move towards a more equitable and sustainable coffee economy where the economic realities of farmers are better understood and addressed.

Annette Pensel, Executive Director of the Global Coffee Platform, emphasized the critical need for collective action and innovation in measurement. “I believe it’s time to collaborate on new ways of measurement to better understand what our collective efforts change for farmers,” Pensel stated, underscoring the imperative to evolve beyond traditional metrics. The industry’s ability to adapt its procurement strategies and to accurately measure the true impact of its sustainability endeavors will be crucial in determining the future of coffee farming and the livelihoods of millions dependent on it. The current dip in reported sustainable coffee purchases, while concerning, may serve as a catalyst for deeper introspection and a renewed commitment to more impactful and equitable solutions.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *