In a significant transition within the vibrant Ohio coffee scene, Boardman’s beloved Branch Street Coffee Roasters has officially passed the torch to two of its most dedicated employees, Troy Metzger and Joshua Mitchell, who will now steer the independent cafe forward under the new banner of Denizen Coffee. The ownership change, finalized on November 6th, marks the culmination of a year-long succession plan orchestrated by Branch Street founders Matthew and Kristin Campbell. While the financial specifics of the deal remain undisclosed, the move signifies a new chapter for the cherished establishment, which has been a cornerstone of the Youngstown-area community for over a decade.
The Campbells, who established Branch Street Coffee Roasters in 2015, will continue their involvement in the coffee industry through their established wholesale roasting operation. Their Glenwood production facility will remain the hub for Branch Street Coffee Roasters, ensuring a continued supply of their acclaimed beans. Crucially, Denizen Coffee has secured a partnership with the Campbells, guaranteeing that the cafe will continue to serve Branch Street’s signature coffees, both as brewed beverages and available for retail purchase in-store and online. This symbiotic relationship ensures a seamless transition for loyal patrons who have come to appreciate the quality and craftsmanship associated with the Branch Street brand.
A Decade of Dedication and a Vision for the Future
The ascent of Metzger and Mitchell to ownership is a testament to their deep commitment and extensive experience within the Branch Street ecosystem. Metzger, a decade-long veteran, has been instrumental in shaping the cafe’s operational excellence and customer service ethos. Mitchell, who joined the team six years ago after relocating from North Carolina, has also become an integral part of the cafe’s success. For the past three years, both individuals have been at the helm of the cafe’s daily operations, honing their leadership skills and developing a profound understanding of the business and its clientele.

The impetus for the ownership transition stemmed from Matthew Campbell’s increasing professional obligations with Invoke Coffee Equipment, his burgeoning business specializing in espresso machine sales, service, and support. Recognizing the exceptional capabilities and dedication of Metzger and Mitchell, Campbell proactively initiated discussions about their aspirations for the cafe. "With Troy and Joshua doing so well in their leadership roles, I asked them if they ever had a desire to take over ownership and develop the cafe in their own vision," Campbell shared with Daily Coffee News. "They were excited at that prospect and we immediately began to create a succession plan." This proactive approach underscores the Campbells’ commitment to ensuring the longevity and continued success of the cafe, entrusting its future to individuals who have demonstrably proven their passion and expertise.
Continuity and Evolution Under New Management
For the existing customer base, the transition to Denizen Coffee promises a familiar and welcoming experience. The core of the cafe’s appeal – its dedicated staff and well-loved menu – is slated to remain unchanged. This commitment to continuity ensures that the loyal patrons of Branch Street will find the same high standards of service and quality they have come to expect. Furthermore, any outstanding Branch Street gift cards and loyalty rewards will be fully honored by Denizen Coffee, providing a seamless and reassuring experience for customers.
The renaming to Denizen Coffee signifies not just a change in ownership, but also an opportunity for Metzger and Mitchell to imprint their own vision onto the establishment. While the foundational elements will remain, there is an inherent anticipation of subtle evolutions and new initiatives that will reflect their leadership. As "denizens" of the community they serve, Metzger and Mitchell are poised to foster deeper connections and introduce fresh perspectives, building upon the strong legacy established by the Campbells.
A Legacy of Excellence and Community Recognition

Branch Street Coffee Roasters has garnered significant acclaim since its inception in 2015, cultivating a devoted following and earning accolades that highlight its commitment to quality and community engagement. The cafe’s dedication to the craft of coffee was recognized on a national level when it was named the "best coffee" in Ohio by Food & Wine in 2019, a prestigious honor that underscored its position as a leader in the independent coffee movement. The roasting arm of the business has also consistently received high marks from Coffee Review, a respected publication that evaluates and rates coffees from around the globe.
Matthew Campbell articulated the significance of this recognition, emphasizing that such achievements are a collective effort. "While these are noteworthy, none of it is possible without a team of knowledgeable and passionate baristas and roasters, and the community that shows up to keep that business alive," he stated. This sentiment highlights the collaborative spirit that has defined Branch Street and will undoubtedly be a cornerstone of Denizen Coffee’s philosophy. The success of the cafe is not merely a product of the owners’ vision, but a testament to the dedication of its staff and the unwavering support of its patrons.
The Broader Implications for the Local Coffee Landscape
The ownership transfer from Branch Street Coffee Roasters to Denizen Coffee is more than just a local business story; it’s a narrative that resonates with broader trends in the independent coffee industry. The success of this management-to-ownership transition model offers a potential blueprint for other established coffee businesses looking to ensure continuity and foster employee growth. It speaks to the value of investing in and empowering long-term staff, recognizing their intrinsic understanding of the business and their potential to lead it into the future.
This event also reinforces the importance of community-centric businesses. The Campbells’ decision to entrust the cafe to their employees, rather than seeking an external buyer, demonstrates a deep-seated commitment to the people and the place that have been integral to Branch Street’s identity. The continued operation of the wholesale roasting business by the Campbells, while also supplying Denizen, showcases a sophisticated understanding of business diversification and strategic partnerships. This ensures that their expertise in roasting continues to benefit the local market, even as they transition away from direct cafe operations.

The rise of Denizen Coffee, spearheaded by Metzger and Mitchell, signifies a new wave of independent coffee entrepreneurship. Their intimate knowledge of the cafe’s operations, combined with their passion for coffee and community, positions them to build upon the established foundation. The potential for them to introduce new offerings, host community events, and further refine the customer experience, all while maintaining the quality that earned Branch Street its reputation, is significant. This transition is likely to inspire other aspiring coffee professionals in the region, showcasing that dedication and hard work can indeed lead to ownership and the realization of entrepreneurial dreams within a supportive ecosystem.
A Look Ahead: Denizen Coffee’s Trajectory
The cafe, now officially Denizen Coffee, is located at 1393 Boardman-Canfield Rd in Boardman, Ohio. This address has become a landmark for coffee enthusiasts in the region, and under the new ownership, it is poised to continue its legacy of excellence. The strategic decision to retain the existing staff and menu provides immediate stability, while the new ownership’s fresh perspective offers exciting possibilities for future growth and innovation.
The successful transfer of ownership from Branch Street Coffee Roasters to Denizen Coffee represents a positive evolution for the local coffee scene. It highlights the enduring strength of independent coffee businesses, the importance of dedicated employees, and the power of well-planned succession. As Denizen Coffee embarks on its journey, the community eagerly anticipates the unique contributions Metzger and Mitchell will bring, further solidifying the region’s reputation as a hub for exceptional coffee and vibrant local enterprises. The story of Denizen Coffee is a compelling testament to the cyclical nature of business, where established legacies pave the way for new chapters, driven by passion, expertise, and a deep connection to the community they serve.
